Rule~ I think needs to be altered to be fair

If you have screeshots that enough ... The point is that there is not a way to make sure they were griefing before thay were killed .. there is also not a way to know who the owner of the items was .

 

if they got screenshots, how could they get it when they are dead.
If the island is missing, lets say, a diamond block, and a diamond block is/was in his inventory, I think you can guess, even though as a mod you can only work with evidence

 

?

 

I think that this should be a rule. There must be no mod/staff on and you must ask them to leave first. Although, just in case, you might want to get some form of documentation (video/screenshot) to show that they and not you were breaking the rules before you go ahead and kill them. That way if you get banned or a staff member questions you, you can defend yourself. You should have this proof because unlike most of the other rules, this one is hard to catch them breaking it because the conditions of you being allowed to kill them are that there are no mods on, so if there are no mods on, you or another non-staff-member player has to report them with evidence.

 

This is exactly the point I'm making. Whoever kills will say that all of these requirements are met, and if no screenshots are taken, we have no solid way to find out.

Anyhow, I think I've made my opinion clear enough at this point. I don't think the rule should be changed.

 

Honestly, getting killed by lava is also easily avoidable. As you may be able to see in this old report- [.net] shampoomohawk [Attempting to Kill] | Skyblock Forums

I easily survived a lava killing just by wearing gold armor with fire protection. Sometimes, I wished I could kill players who were griefing. If someone goes offline on your island you may place a chamber around them, telling them to leave. If they break it, they will be banned for griefing.

 

that works in theory, but if you do not know where they logged off, that cannot work. Also people who have /fly, they log of in the air, it is nearly impossible to block/catch them. again, logs sometimes fail and they clear so there are none.


I see a lot of people are missing the point. I am only trying to get this allowed, under EXTREME CIRCUMSTANCES. Only as a last resolution this should be allowed, and if so, with a lot of evidence so you can prove that, under those extreme circumstances, you could kill them.

 

So you're saying that whoever does the killing must have solid evidence proving that it was justifiable?

 

Hahahha darkslash the probblem here is that I think you might be to nice .. The problem with this and why this wont probably happen is because not everyone is going to be like you and kill only in extreme circumstances . People might kill the other player just to get their stuff ... and there is no way to know if it was a grief or because they were going to grief .

 

yes, that is what I have been saying. I have also updated the main post so it makes much more sense

I have updated the origional post. That explains more about this

 

This makes people know when they can kill. If you are caught killing, and the reason is unjustifiable with evidence, the killer will be banned, and the killed will be refunded. So they need to be caught griefing, with screenshots, and all other possibilities were exhausted, for them to be allowed to kill

 

A bit more agreeable, but it'll still cause more complications then there needs to be.

 

I just spleef them and hope if they can do /home in time

 

Just trade at skybase. Don't tp people that you don't know at your island. No support.

 

Why isn't there just a kick command to kick someone from your island that arent coop?

 

Because it's be near impossible to add.

 

Valiice that would be a lot of work, and I'm not sure if it is possible.

 

Full Support.
I deffintly agree of what Flutters said.

 

Sorry, but as a natural instinct, Liturally no one would do that. All of us humans would obviously try to do something about the grief. Not just stand there and record.

It's like saying:
Oh no! I trusted this guy to build something cool on my island and he's not doing that! He's going to grief my beacons!

What are you going to do?
Yes, you will try to save those hard - earned beacons.
Not just look at him/her in shock.
However, if you do just stand there, and video the Griefer, expect your beacons to be returned 1 year later or more.