OK, and why do you think they are now saying you didn't trade a DC full of cobble for 1 diamond? Why would they deny you being there?

And why did you pay 1 diamond for a DC of cobble? That is severely over paying?

 

I don't know why they are changing their story after they have already said all that they have.

I was helping out my friend that is a non-donor, didn't really feel like negotiating at the time so just threw out 1 diamond. Also since I paid 1 diamond, I don't see the problem here. They're my diamonds and why are they so mad about it? You said it was "Severely overpaying" So I really don't see the big deal here...

 

eb6293
aki_da_hobo
Please can you both confirm for me. Was XxTobyGamingxX authorised to take the DC of cobble in trade for 1 diamond?

 

Hmm. I never trade my cobble stone since I wanted to expand my island, hence actually trying to keep my cobblestone. So from me, he had to perm to take these cobble.

Ill leave the rest to eb6293

 

I have no idea, as I don't have access to the chest

 

eb6293

So you are saying the chest was locked?

 

Since none of them say they traded with me, is it possible that maybe kds sold me the cobble? Even though it wasn't his... That's all that I can think of at this point.

 

NIH301 , when you checked my chests, you asked me the cests were private.
I said they were. However, when i saw that they weren't there, i THOUGHT i had accidentally broken it.

 

Well, this is all a bit of a mess. Not much is adding up and there are far too many coincidences. The removal of the private sign on the chest, and XxTobyGamingxX then taking the cobble suggests to me that this was indeed a trade. The island owners initially insisting it was a trade, then changing their minds. Inconsistencies on who accessed what and when. It all sticks of a trade gone wrong, or a scam gone wrong.

But.. this is just a DC of cobble we are talking about. I don't think I am being told the whole truth, and to be honest I don't trust any of the parties involved in this. Since I cannot trust the accuser, I have no options but to lift the ban on XxTobyGamingxX.

I will be watching you all. Very closely.

 

Your ban appeal has been accepted.
Thread locked and moved to Ban Appeal Archives.