I think this is quite needed, especially when you don't want to type out a response and you could just react with something. Ideas: Dumb Fair /Fair Enough Generous Upsetting Unlucky Lucky Irrelevant Stonks (as requested by tore) Not funny These are just some ideas, feel free to suggest more.
We already have too many. Some most of us don’t even use. We only need 3; Agree, Disagree, Don’t care. xD
Well some of the current ones are unnecessary and rarely ever used like Old, Bad Spelling, Cookie and Creative. Maybe swap these out for more useful ones. Absolute Genius.
I mean, its a great idea, but definetly not a first priority thing, so imma start with neutral, but it sounds pretty cool.
I don't see the need for any more ratings. It would add clutter to the forums. If you could provide any ideas for what these ratings would look like, it would make your suggestion seem more achievable. The idea of swapping ratings out could be possible, however if they hold a positive or negative value it will affect players quite a lot. Neutral values are not as important to gain or lose as they are neutral (unless the player holds special value to their neutral rating score, it doesn't matter).
Dumb/Silly ongueclosed: Fair: Like some weights: Generous: Upsetting: :disrelieved: Lucky: Clover Unlucky: ^^ Or a black cat or something? Irrelevant: I get these aren't all ideal, (and the size of the pictures, sorry, just pulled them from google) but these or something similar would be good
Dumb rating was once a thing, but it got removed (Not here long enough to know the reason why, but probably flaming/rate abuse/unnecessary). I think new ratings could be unique, but as Agent said, I think it would clutter forums even more, and I think a lot of them would end up being unused anyway, or cause other ratings to become unused.
Adding 1 or 2 ratings would be fine but adding a whole load of ratings that might make the forums more cluttered. So I'm going with neutral
I actually use cookie and creative a lot. Neutral. Dumb rating was removed for a reason. There is too many ratings out there already in my opinion. Adding even more would create clutter as Agent stated.
no-support I think we have enough ratings already and bringing back the dumb rating would just cause problems.
I think the ratings we have are enough. I'm open to having more ratings be added, but the suggested ones seem irrelevant and unnecessary. Some of the ideas provided such as 'dumb', 'irrelevant' and 'not funny' could come off as disrespectful towards the members. However if new ratings do get added, that would be cool too. I guess it's something that's not needed, but would be nice to have if added anyways.
*cough* *cough* I believe 2 new ratings is enough. (Hype Train & Fire) Half of the ratings you mentioned would be pointless & too much. (and cause problems.) If you didn't know the ratings's pixels changed, I used it for a overhaul suggestion. (The 2 new ratings would be both positive.)
