But they wouldn’t be able to sell the items to other players, people can be island farming right now as we speak, introducing this wouldn’t effect it

 

What if the supplies were for themselves and they needed it?

 

We can say that about now though haha

 

This is actually a very smart way to legalize dirt and sand! Support!!

 

There's a distinction between grass and dirt. Dirt, like OP said, would still be illegal to trade under the proposed rules.

Therefore, the use of grass as currency would remain unaffected.

 

I would support the sand trade but not the dirt. The reasoning behind why I think that dirt trade should stay illegal is because you could get alternate accounts and then you could take the dirt and it could make people without alt accounts at an unfair advantage Plus I think sand trade should be legal due to the fact that pretty much only donors get sand

 

Support! The buying sand at /warp trade is a great idea because 1) It'll stop people heavily overcharging for red sand and 2) If you are buying bulk sand, you won't have to sit there at your converter converting it all which can be rather boring and annoying.
Not sure about the dirt. It is a good idea but I think it would probably work best if it didn't give you too much per grass, personally I'd say 2 dirt per grass block.

Great ideas though James!

 

Update: due to public discussion, people have voted not to have dirt in the villagers.
Just sand.

 

That sounds a lot better

 

Support! This would be a great fix. Island farming has always been somewhat annoying, and to think that the majority of stuff you get on it anyway is being sold, sand should be included. I can't wait to this to be added!

 

Thanks guys

 

Support! I know you can buy red sand, but I don't have a converter at the moment, and it'd be nice to have quicker access to it (as opposed to waiting for my kit, or building a converter and buying red sand).

 

FULL support tit will cause less island farmers and help More people who want to terraform their islands I also think we should get a /warp donor for better trades for us who donated maybe you could make a thread on that

 

Thank you

 

Support. Great idea. I have been frustrated with both parts (illegal dirt and sand) for the past times I've been playing on this server. Plus red sand is really hard to get.

 

Neutral.

It's a great idea, but I have some whereabouts, regarding the trading. Though I would like to see it being a thing in game

 

Skylords and up can also get sand from kits but for the non-donors, it can be a challenge. I think for the difficulty of it makes it more of a survival type game instead of just buying sand.

 

Very true but I seem to remember getting sand in my Skyking kit haha