You are missing the whole point of having a leaf sword! If you want leaf blocks, use shears. If you want saplings, use a leaf sword. If you want neither, use either and toss it. If you don't care if the leaves are broken immediately, wait.

Do you disagree that /kit sapling only gives oak and that /ma j is too slow for any large amount?

 

What's the point?It's point less! You have silk touch and leaves grow on trees! You can easily get sapling from /ma j.
Therefor, no support!

Well how els can you get leaves and plus /kit saplings gives you a sapling to get wood and leaves that's the purpose of it! You'll manage like all of us!

Look, there's auto farms! When I was on a day or 2 ago I was using 1 and I got saplings instantly!

 

Could just call it a sapling sword then.

I love how this guy is still fighting for his lead sword even though it will never happen.
You already got a few no supports. Just accept them and move on lol.

 

NEVER

Ok I get it you hate the leaf sword. You've made your point (that I invalidated) so just move on!

 

Okay.....
no
This is pointless. Make a tree farm and quit ur whining.

 

I have not before heard about this "leaf sword," or its enchants, and I have been getting along fine with just either patiently waiting for the leaves to decay and drop saplings, or breaking them with my axe. I don't see why it should be much of a problem that this is no longer apart of the server. I can see how this could benefit, but I honestly don't think it would bring much change to the server.

 

WELL, maybe if you weren't so tideous about the way you do things on a BLOCKGAME server this really wouldnt be a problem, because it's never been a problem with anyone in the past.

 

A. No they aren't
B. There is no need for large scale as the crusher removes the leaves for you to grow more leaves in its place thus only needing a small crusher
C. This whole thread is just waiting for you to receive support and any no supports are wrong or don't understand

 

Its not a problem (wish I could change the title lol), its a possibility for awesomeness.
(EDIT: oh wait, I can!)

Alright fine, this is (mostly) a valid point. But really? Only one point against this?
(EDIT: I take that back, piston crushers only work for simpler trees like oak and birch.)

Please read post #19, I already addressed all these.

The leaf sword is the only way to quickly remove leaves AND get tons of saplings.

 

Step 1: get shears
Step 2: enchant shears
Step 3: remove leaves
Step 4: create piston that extends/retracts rapidly with hoppers around it
Step 5: simply spam leaves onto piston
Step 6: profit


Literally something that took 5 seconds of thought and a google search to check pistons/leaves

 

Ok that will work, but with a leaf sword:
Step 1: get sword
Step 2: enchant into leaf sword
Step 3: remove leaves
Step 4: profit

Literally something that took 5 seconds to think of.

 

Requires devs to add back god plugin, and non vanilla enchantments. I and everyone else prefers fun gameplay and problem solving over a constant grind that makes even more profit for those who have /god perks

Face it. This is never gonna happen. Skyblock.net is vanilla skyblock and if you don’t like that, find another server.

 

No it doesn't its easy to do just /give @p diamond_sword 1 0 {ench:[{id:32,lvl:5},{id:35,lvl:3}]} they can VERY quickly put it in warp trade or something so everyone has access to it.

And is it more grinding to break blocks instantly or not break them instantly?
This is vanilla, you can do it without mods and even without commands.

 

But really? This is such a small feature and people have thought of so many counter points to it. And I have thought of so many counter-counter points. In reality I am willing for this to never be in skyblock.net, I just don't like to let someone present a point that is faulty and not point that out.

 

Oh this is gonna be fun....

There you go. See. Not Vanilla Enchantments, ie, stuff minecraft will not normally let you put on a sword.
Warp trade is simple and easy, until you realize they have to figure out how to price it, what kind of sword, and then figure out how to balance it.

When everyone has infinite saplings, then you start needing infinite time to keep up with competition. (This results in "grinding" for those of you who can't understand simple logic/reasoning) This would unbalance the wood prices, which is the main source of income for the gravitationally challenged. Woops there goes the economy and player base.

.....

No you have mostly just responded rudely and restated your original point.

Oh so now you are telling me you started this thread because you knew it would start an argument? In suggestions none the less? This is supposed to be a part of forums where player discuss their ideas for improving the server, not somewhere to start a pointless argument you clearly don't even care about. You are the definition of an internet troll.

*Flashback to your previous post....*

Hypocrite

So this was to what? Start a random argument, lose respect among other players and improve your post count?

Interesting how you decided to make a post boasting about your ability to annoy valued members of the community and detail the reasons why you are in the wrong...

 

Wow stop taking me so literal.

/give is just one way to do it. You can do it in creative mode as well. Now who's being rude?

No I wanted to get a leaf sword. This is the place to ask for it isn't it? Although the posts comment was a bit off topic...

This is what we are doing. I think leaf swords would improve the server, you don't. And we are discussing it!

I'm sorry to have upset you, it was not my intention.


Now then are we talking about me or the leaf sword, because I would like to get back on track here. Can we please do that instead of criticizing each other instead of our points? This is starting to get out of hand here.

This is more like it! Anyway you are correct as long as the leaf sword gives infinite saplings.

I'd hate to restate my original point again, but it looks like I have no choice. You look like you need it from another point of view:

A leaf sword: like using a fortune axe but instant, like using shears or pistons but fortune.
Nothing is infinite, it just makes life simpler, and easier to get more saplings, and cheaper so you don't need pistons, and nicer looking, and all this opposition is kind of tiring.

One more thing: to chop a tree, break leaves for a sapling, and replant without a leaf sword takes about 10 seconds. With a leaf sword it is 8 seconds. Wow. That is SOO big a difference as to completely upset the skyblock economy.

 

A) No, I correctly stated a fact. You are being hypocritical
B) You said you don't even care, so clearly no, you didn't start this for the leaf sword you started it for the argument you have lost many times over now.
C) We are discussing the reasons why we don't don't need this, you are just saying we are wrong without actually proving it
D) You first on the not criticizing each other. I have only criticized you when you were clearly contradicting yourself.
E) Better get used to the opposition you suddenly stopped enjoying, because that is how this part of forums works.

 

If you want I can show you how to get a leaf sword in vanilla without commands or mods. If you still think so, tell me specifically what I'm hypocritical in.

I never said I don't care. I said I was willing for it to not be added, but I want it to be added.

I'd be happy to provide proof. What did I say that you don't you believe?

And with this comment you just criticized me! Really stop it you can do this in pm, not in the suggestions forum of all places. You can criticize the points or comments but don't say it is bad give meaningful reasons why.

I never said I enjoyed the opposition, I said it was just tiring. Let me clarify: the comments that arn't talking about the leaf sword (like the one above this ^^) are tiring. Please don't post comments criticizing me in this forum. If you really need to, you can do that in game.

If no one else has anything helpful (about the leaf sword (this includes points like use pistons instead)) to say then this discussion is OVER. I want to hear REASONS why the leaf sword is good or bad not just that is is bad. Use the poll and go if that is all you have to say.

 

Alright. I clearly can't lose enough brain cells to explain this to you in detail.

No Support.

 

not really any need. I can see hat you want something to get more saplings and I think it’d be an interesting addition but it could allow specific people to have a monopoly on the sapling situation and could seriously change the wood market. I’m not sure if that is desirable or not, so I stand neutral on the idea.