Because I don't want to allow flying of any kind on my island? .... actually I was gonna type a longer response but I see you're simply being a troll so I'll let you enjoy and leave the suggestion open to anyone with actual feedback that's useful. Good day Butter.

 

You've disagreed to my reply on this thread without reason, what is the disagreement? You cant stop people using baritone, noclip, schematic downloads. There is no physical way. What is there to disagree about? Its a fact not an opinion...


Its just not that big of an issue.
It doesn't really require being an addition to the game, it removes the point of elytras.

If your so upset over someone flying around your island, lock it. If you don't want to lock it then build a box around things that you don't want people to access, like every other person in the history of this game gang

At the end of the day people will always find ways to get into places that they are not meant to

 

^ this exactly, we've stated this multiple times CraftWithAbbie so we are not trolls, this is the reason it's an unneccesary nerf to an expensive item thats underpowered as is

 

Suggestions are a place for anyone to give an idea big or small on how to improve the server. Players can react with support no support or neutral. Players can disagree about suggestions. That's what the ratings are for. However They aren't a place to start an argument. You've left your valuble feedback now, so respectfully move on.

 

We fully explained why its not needed..

 

Bumping this suggestion. Being able to choose if you want players using elytras across your island should be an option for the island owners that turn /Fly off too.

I've attached an example photo of how elytras are used currently to travel through half or 1 block gaps, which unlike fly, they allow for a swimming movement.

 

No support. Honestly, elytras are just really fun and valuable and I see no reason to limit their utility. You buy an elytra to fly, not to just wear for the sake of it. I’ve never come across an issue where banning elytras would solve it.

As others have stated, banning elytras won’t do anything for warping through one-block gaps. Free-camming exists. The only way to solve that is to lock your island, nothing else. I would honestly really dislike it if this was a new island setting, no offence to OP.

 

Help step-Steve I'm stuck D:

 

Sure there are other ways a player could Glitch. Through gaps, but the standard casino is set up with a door that lock when a player is actively in the casino playing, so this would benefit .out users that have that setup.

As others state its a nerf. Ill point out that it isn't a nerf to elytras, as that would be pointless. It's simply a better way of allowing no fly settings on an individuals island. The 99% of the rest of the server islands that turn /fly to true and allow fly on their isles, it won't be any different. They can continue without disabling any aspect of fly through their isle settings.

None taken, we both just have different opinions on how it could or couldn't be helpful that's all.

Lmao

 

I completely agree with this post. Elytras are just /fly with extra steps.

 

I think they should've been disabled from the get-go, but because this suggestion is coming late, players have gotten used to having the ability to use elytra on islands with flight disabled. Some even buy it specifically for that purpose, hence my no support.

Now you just have to secure your casinos and afk chambers properly instead of leaving a gap for players to fly through.

 

But let's be realistic here, literally noones gonna go do that. And 99% of casinos are set up with a one block piston door like this.

The suggestion isn't necessarily about disabling and nerfing elytras. I use them and love gliding around and bouncing with them. It's more just a personal preference. For everyone that turns fly off on their islands, elytras bypass that which I feel should be an optional preference is all. I'm sure most players won't care about elytras being used on their islands. But there's a few that certainly do.

 

This is, by definition, a nerf. It reduces an elytra's ability to function and makes it less powerful.

If you want to do the minimal amount of work, just replace them with fences or walls.

 

If you are smart enough to operate a piston door, you are smart enough to make it anti-elytra. It’s literally just putting the top pistons one-block lower.

 

I put no support, but other than most of the reasons stated, most of the reasons you have mentioned seem to just be because of style or play choice not because of gamebreaking problems or an overwhelming abuse of elytra’s on the server. One block gaps on casinos are a design choice because it looks nicer, mine has no gap, it’s just a personal choice. Parkour and mazes etc are just supposed to be a bit of fun, if anyone “cheats” using an elytra it’s only their own fun they remove doesn’t really hurt anyone else. Any other one block gaps on islands that people are using elytra’s to get into, again design choice, don’t have a 1 block gap on a place where you specifically don’t want people to get to. We don’t need to jump to disabling a fundamental part of the elytra’s usage over a few personal design choices.

 

Then my question to all the no supports, is this:

What do you expect to gain, from being able to fly on islands where the Isle owner wishes players not to fly on?

Because by that logic we may aswell not have /fly as an optional toggle. Simply because people can just use elytras.

 

I expect that eleytra's are very expensive and have little us other than a collectors item. One of the only times they come in handy when /fly is off, so we don't have to move around like ants to explore an island.

Example: Drogo's island is huge and has no /fly

 

I wish

 

I agree that they're expensive and very useful to fly around. But then that invalidates everyone else who disables fly on their own islands. People can decide to not allow flying on their island. Thats why it's there as a preference.

But then that comes down to each person's preference too. You may prefer to fly around an island that the owner turned fly off on, but that doesn't give you the Right to fly around it.

Just like how hacks are allowed on everyone's islands, but it depends on the Isle owner and at spawn hacks are disabled. That's not nerfing hacks, just as the odd few isle owners that wish no types of fly, should have that as a preference.


To me, and this is just a thought, but it seems like the people in this thread actually wanting elytras, purely to fly around unflyable islands, are the ones who'd use them to grief with anyway smh,, lmao.

 

Because it's cool to zoom out. Freecam is banned. I can't check the adjacent islands easy. Exporting bobby is too long of a process.

I have never griefed an island though.. moving? I don't play parkour in any way that "ruins it" to fly. (competitively, I don't play competitive parkour).