Which Grinder is more Superior?

Today XDisawesome & I each built a mob grinder for Heyitstalia. XDisAwesome's build's the taller one :3 We were discussing which grinder was better, so...I'll leave it to you people I mean, his build's the better one quite obviously, right?

Overall View of Both Grinders

The Collection Point of Source's Grinder

The Collection Point of XDisAwesome's Grinder

The Back Side of Source's Grinder

The Back Side of XDisAwesome's Grinder

By the way, this's just a friendly thing, nothing serious

 

Cool

 

Is there a bridge? I can't tell if that line of blocks is part of the island or not?

 

No idea...things are all over the place on her island...she has sets of diamond armor, ore blocks, etc. unprotected too :L I'm worried...

 

Oh ok lol and tell her she should really do something about that she doesn't want to get griefed

 

Already did a few times :/

 

I'm in her coop, no she did /new island and we spawned next to our old island

 

What're the odds for that? -.-

 

Lol, I locked up.

And I think both of your grinders are beautiful. Just really laggy.

 

Haha XD The lag isn't 'cause of the grinders. It's 'cause you have like, 100 mobs on your island. :/

 

I SHALL KILL ERITHING

 

Nuu~ Not the doggies. :'(

 

I feel like they are both too tall. My grinder is much shorter. When you are closer to the spawners, they spawn. Some grinders are too tall and it's hard to get them to spawn.

 

Isn't it just within the chunk? Also, creepers have much more health points than sheeps :3 Baaaa~

 

Within 16 blocks.

 

Oh...my Minecraft knowledge is outdated. I did make a platform around the spawning area where she can stay AFK just in case my information was wrong. So that should do the job.

 

I've always loved structurally supporting builds in MC. One of the under utilized build ways to go.

 

Yours looks nice source, but dis,s seems to have a bigger fall, and in efficiency termsv that is a very good thing

 

She wanted Exp Points X3