Accepted Appeal

Discussion in 'Appeals Archive' started by TortoiseSpeed, Feb 4, 2024.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. TortoiseSpeed
    Offline

    TortoiseSpeed Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jun 15, 2014
    Messages:
    306
    I would just like to start out with in saying that I will be representing myself in this matter. I have no professional litigation experience or background.

    Punished account name: WhySoDelicious
    Platform or server punished on: Skyblock
    Ban message if applicable: Island Farming
    Have you read the rules? No
    Do you think this punishment was incorrect? Yes
    Why should you be unbanned? In the last 10 years, I could count the amount of times I started up and played Minecraft on my hands. For whatever reason, the basic decor of landscape, "Grass" is this servers currency. I do not control that. I understand the appeal of having a prestigious island with diamond blocks and bedazzlement. However, my island is merely organic foliage that would take me weeks to build with the daily grass block I receive. I do not profit off of what I do nor do I find pleasure in breaking the rules.

    I would like to know why what I am doing is wrong and not merely cosmetic.

    Why is it the Silk Touch is disabled on shovels? Why is it that dirt trade is illegal? Why is it that /newisland replace has a 3 minute cooldown vs perhaps a few hours? I am not taking these items and turning them into Currency to give myself a competitive advantage. I am placing them on my island for where they will stay.


    I tried discussing this with KingKong but he just kept repeating to me that I was breaking the rules when I was inquiring about why this was.

    Please list any other times you were punished on Skyblock: N/A
    If you know, tag the staff member that banned you: KingKong
    Do you understand and accept our rules and code of conduct? Absolutely
     
  2. luka
    Offline

    luka macdondalds Super Moderator Premium

    Joined:
    Apr 10, 2016
    Messages:
    3,840
    Discord:
    houzo
    IGN:
    Houzo
  3. TortoiseSpeed
    Offline

    TortoiseSpeed Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jun 15, 2014
    Messages:
    306
    I also am requesting a formal apology additionally for my appeal.

    I decided to take a nostalgic trip and rekindle some childhood memories. Found a minecraft tutorial and decided to build a house. Wanted to add grass around that house. Had no grass. Found a solution, for which at the time I thought was creative on my part, how the tables turned I did not expect.

    Minding my own business when out of nowhere I am approached by KingJohnSnow. They could not properly articulate what it is I had done wrong other than it was against the rules. How simple would it have been to just confiscate the items and asked me to stop? Not a very constructive way to moderate by just banning someone without a warning?

    Am I going to far to compare this to this hypothetical situation?:

    A law enforcement officer (KingJohn) approaches a civilian (Myself) ask me “What are you doing?” I reply with what I am doing. Without even hesitation, the law enforcement officer (KingJohn) reaches for his weapon and shoots me in the face, multiple times.

    I think that is an incredibly accurate depiction of what took place on skyblock earlier today.
     
  4. KingJonSnow
    Offline

    KingJonSnow Moderator Moderator

    Joined:
    Aug 26, 2019
    Messages:
    217
    IGN:
    KingJonSnow
    Hi WhySoDelicious, I will be the one answering your appeal since I was the one who banned you. First of all, it isn't a good look nor appropriate to try and make nicknames as jokes agains the one who banned you on the server.

    I saw you island farming and instantly taking the dirt you broke back to another island to place them. I didn't want to assume that you knew the rules so I reached out to ask you why you were taking the dirt that you farmed from the other island and placing it on another island. You responded with "So I don't have to use grass." I replied to you that this was against the rules and is considered island farming. Your response was "I am using it for decoration." and when I responded that it doesn't matter as it is still island farming and against the rules, you responded with "It's okay." From what I can see from the logs that I pulled, there are 192 pages with 4 items per page of you placing dirt on the island I found it on. You seemed to not care that it was agains the rules since "I am not taking these items and turning them into Currency to give myself a competitive advantage. I am placing them on my island for where they will stay." Regardless of your belief that this was okay, it is not in fact okay as it breaks the rules of the server. I even asked you how many islands you had farmed to get a better grasp and give you an opportunity to see what you were doing was wrong since I did articulate it was against the rules and was not allowed on the server. You continued to hold to the narrative that what you were doing wasn't wrong so I banned you per server guidelines for breaking rules. In case you were wondering, here is a link and the rule you broke in question.

    Screenshot 2024-02-04 at 9.06.32 PM.png

    https://skyblock.net/threads/skyblock-server-rules.137983/

    There were logs showing around 700 dirt was placed on your island so the action I took was warranted per server rules.


    I do not believe I need to apologize to you for issuing a punishment that is line with the rule that you broke. Not once in my messages to you did you admit that what you did was wrong or against the rules. It also seems that you still don't per your appeal where you believe you should be allowed to island farm since it isn't hurting anyone and isn't for personal gain.

    Do you now understand why you were punished on the server?
     
  5. TortoiseSpeed
    Offline

    TortoiseSpeed Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jun 15, 2014
    Messages:
    306
    Unnecessary opinion as it is irrelevant to the appeal.

    So was I banned because I did not seem apologetic enough or was I banned because I broke the rules "per server guidelines"?

    Hearsay

    Do not worry, I should be apologizing to you. I did not know how serious of an offense this was. I am extremely embarrassed. The little respect I had on this server, if any, is squashed. It is people like me that ruin it for everyone else.

    Today I jeopardized the integrity of the server, and I come to wonder, is a one week ban enough? I think this should be 2, 3, maybe 4 weeks? To give me time to read all the rules twice over and understand how my actions, make the server an unsafe environment. I am a disgrace. A pathetic waste of cells. And for that, I am so very sorry.
     
  6. TortoiseSpeed
    Offline

    TortoiseSpeed Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jun 15, 2014
    Messages:
    306
    KingJonSnow No in all seriousness I apologize and won't Island Farm again. I was not embarrassed I broke the rules I was embarrassed I got caught. Also, did not mean to insult you by miswriting your name I was going off of memory. I will take my ban. Take care
     
  7. KingJonSnow
    Offline

    KingJonSnow Moderator Moderator

    Joined:
    Aug 26, 2019
    Messages:
    217
    IGN:
    KingJonSnow
    Thank you for your apology and being honest in your last post. I wanted to give you the benefit of the doubt since I didn't want to assume you knew the rules with my initial conversation. Since you did break rules and weren't forthcoming in your initial responses, it will still result in a ban, but since your punishment history is clean and it appears this is the first time you have broken rules, I will be shortening your ban from 7 days to 4 days. Since you are just coming back for nostalgia, I would recommend looking over the rules to make sure things haven't changed since the last time you were playing.
     
  8. KingJonSnow
    Offline

    KingJonSnow Moderator Moderator

    Joined:
    Aug 26, 2019
    Messages:
    217
    IGN:
    KingJonSnow
    Thank you for creating an appeal, your appeal has been accepted!
    Please make sure that you read our rules here before continuing on as normal!
    Thread closed and moved to Appeals Archive.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page